about us

Your Preliminary Hearing Is the First Real Chance to Fight the Charges

A preliminary hearing notice in your hand means the clock is already running. This stage — often misunderstood and routinely underused — can result in charges dismissed or reduced before your case ever reaches the Court of Common Pleas. I represent clients at preliminary hearings throughout Franklin County and surrounding counties, and I treat this stage as the strategic opportunity it is.

What Actually Happens at a Preliminary Hearing in Pennsylvania

A preliminary hearing is held before a Magisterial District Judge, not a jury and not a trial court. The standard the Commonwealth must meet is probable cause — a lower bar than what's required for conviction, but a real one. The judge must find sufficient evidence that a crime occurred and that you are the person who committed it before the case can proceed to the Court of Common Pleas.

 

This hearing is not a formality. It is a structured proceeding where the evidence against you is presented for the first time in open court. Witnesses can be cross-examined. Evidence can be challenged. Charges that lack support at this stage can be dismissed entirely, and charges that are overcharged can sometimes be reduced before the case moves forward.

 

What this means for you in practical terms:

 

  • The preliminary hearing is often the earliest point at which the defense can directly challenge the Commonwealth's case
  • Effective cross-examination at this stage can reveal weaknesses the prosecution will carry into every proceeding that follows
  • A reduction or dismissal here avoids the cost, time, and risk of litigation at the Court of Common Pleas
  • The hearing also creates a negotiation point with the District Attorney's office — one that disappears if the case moves forward unchallenged

Waive or Contest — This Decision Requires Analysis, Not a Default

One of the most consequential decisions in any criminal case happens before most defendants fully understand what they're deciding. Many are advised to waive the preliminary hearing without a serious review of the facts. Sometimes waiving is the right call. Sometimes it is a significant missed opportunity.

 

I do not have a blanket policy on waiving. I review the specific facts of your case — the charges, the evidence, the witnesses, the jurisdiction — and advise you on whether contesting the hearing gives us a meaningful advantage. That analysis is part of what you're retaining me to do.

What Representation at This Stage Actually Looks Like

Walking into a preliminary hearing unprepared is one of the most common mistakes I see. Some defendants show up without counsel. Others arrive with an attorney they met for the first time that morning in the hallway outside the courtroom. Neither scenario gives you the defense this stage can provide.

 

When I represent a client at a preliminary hearing, I review the criminal complaint and affidavit of probable cause before we ever appear, identify the witnesses the Commonwealth intends to call, prepare a cross-examination strategy, and advise you fully on what to expect before you step into that courtroom. Preparation is not optional at this stage — it is the entire point.

Preliminary Hearing Defense Across Franklin County and Surrounding Counties

I handle preliminary hearings before Magisterial District Judges throughout Franklin County and have represented clients in Adams, Cumberland, and Perry counties as well. Twenty years of practice in south-central Pennsylvania means I am familiar with the local court culture, the judges, and the District Attorney's offices that will be across the table from us. That familiarity matters at every stage of a case, and it matters most at the earliest ones.

Why This Stage Is Worth Taking Seriously

Preliminary hearing representation is often the most cost-effective investment in a criminal defense. A case that is dismissed or significantly reduced at this stage never becomes a trial. It never becomes months of litigation. It never becomes the worst-case outcome you are worried about right now.

 

The defendants who benefit most from strong preliminary hearing representation are the ones who retained counsel early — before the hearing, not after. If you have received a preliminary hearing notice, now is the time to act.

 

  • Court-appointed by Franklin County for criminal, juvenile delinquency, and dependency matters — local judicial credibility built over two decades
  • Trial-tested and prepared to take cases through every stage, including preliminary hearings where many attorneys treat the stage as a pass-through
  • Consultation fee credited toward your retainer if you hire me — you are not paying twice
  • Single-attorney coverage if your matter involves overlapping criminal, juvenile, or family issues

Frequently Asked Questions About Preliminary Hearings in Pennsylvania

  • What is the purpose of a preliminary hearing in Pennsylvania?

    A preliminary hearing determines whether the Commonwealth has sufficient evidence — probable cause — to hold your case for the Court of Common Pleas. It is not a trial, and the standard is lower than conviction, but it is a genuine legal proceeding where charges can be dismissed or reduced if the evidence does not hold up under scrutiny.

  • Should I hire a lawyer for my preliminary hearing in Pennsylvania?

    Yes. The preliminary hearing is one of the most strategic points in a criminal case, and it is also one of the most frequently underestimated. An attorney can cross-examine witnesses, challenge the evidence, and potentially secure a dismissal or reduction before your case escalates. Arriving without counsel — or with an attorney you just met — significantly limits what can be accomplished at this stage.

  • What happens if I waive my preliminary hearing?

    Waiving means you give up the opportunity to challenge the Commonwealth's evidence at this stage, and your case moves directly to the Court of Common Pleas. Waiving is not always the wrong decision, but it should be a deliberate strategic choice based on the facts of your case — not a reflexive default. I advise every client on this decision before we appear.

  • Can charges be dismissed at a preliminary hearing?

    Yes. If the Commonwealth cannot establish probable cause for a charge, the Magisterial District Judge can dismiss it. Charges can also be reduced at this stage, either through the hearing itself or through negotiation with the District Attorney's office that the hearing creates leverage for.

  • How do I find a preliminary hearing attorney in Chambersburg or Franklin County, PA?

    Taccino Law Office handles preliminary hearings throughout Franklin County and in Adams, Cumberland, and Perry counties. You can schedule a consultation by calling 717-262-2319 or submitting a contact form. The consultation fee is credited toward your retainer if you hire me.

Facing a Preliminary Hearing? Let's Review Your Case Before You Appear.

You should never walk into a preliminary hearing without understanding what's at stake and what your options are. I offer paid consultations — credited toward your retainer — so you can get a clear picture of your situation and a strategy before the hearing date arrives. Call 717-262-2319 or use the contact form to get started.